Sweet Valley Twins #44: Amy Moves In

SVT044The Moral of the Story: Tell the truth and be yourself! Otherwise, you have to be friends with the Unicorns.

The Big Deal: Fire!


The Suttons’ house burns down and Amy moves in with the Wakefields while her parents look for a new place to live. Since this is the biggest thing to happen in Sweet Valley since the latest kidnapping/murder, Jessica is thrilled to have Amy in her house. She calls the Unicorns to come over and makes Amy tell them her story. Everyone is convinced Amy had to jump out the window and that’s how she broke her arm, and Amy is interrupted every time she tries to dispute the story (she actually broke it when she tripped over her shoelace). When Amy realizes the Unicorns are actually interested in what she has to say, she starts playing into their drama and embellishing her story. Only Liz knows the truth.

When Liz sends Jessica away so she and Amy can get ready for bed, Jessica starts feeling all hurt and jealous. Liz was spending all her time with Amy even before the Suttons’ house burned down and now she’s trying to hog all of Amy’s time. She sends Liz downstairs to make breakfast the next morning while she braids a purple ribbon into Amy’s hair. Then she calls Lila and arranges to have Mr. Fowler take her and Amy to school. There’s no room for Liz in Mr. Fowler’s car, of course, but she insists Amy take the ride because she needs to “take it easy” right now. You know, because she has a broken arm.

The Unicorns make Amy sit with them at lunch so she can tell them her super exciting story. When they start asking what might have caused the fire, Amy squirms because she’s pretty sure it was all her fault. She had made a fire in the fireplace that night and apparently shoveled the ashes into a paper bag because she’s so smart. So that’s why she acts kind of bitchy when Liz says she wants to interview Amy for the Sixers. Amy says she’d rather not work with Liz; she wants to write the story herself.

Things are tense between Liz and Amy, and it gets worse when Jessica brings home a ton of clothes for Amy donated by the Unicorns. She’s also eating lunch with them every day. The only time she hangs out with Liz is when she needs someone to do something for her. Because, you know, she can’t do anything for herself with the cast on her arm. She feels crappy for the way she’s been treating Liz, especially when she accidentally lets it slip to the Unicorns that Liz sleeps with a stuffed koala bear.

Liz yells at Amy about the way she’s been acting, and Amy moves into Jessica’s room that night. But Jessica’s room kind of sucks because Amy’s sick of hearing about how Liz’s sleeping with a stuffed animal has ruined Jessica’s life. Then she gets roped into spending the entire weekend with the Unicorns, but now they seem to be growing tired of her and her stupid fire story. They’ve moved onto other things, like helping Brooke Dennis prepare for her upcoming party.

Liz notices that the Unicorns have kind of ditched Amy, and she feels bad. She starts speaking to Amy again, and Amy apologizes and everything is okay again. The very next day, Amy’s parents come over and say they’ve found a new house that they can move into that week and it’s only a block away from the Wakefields’ house. Also, they’ve found out the cause of the fire was faulty wiring, so Amy’s off the hook for that. Everything is back to normal.


“Why don’t you go downstairs and help Mom with breakfast, Elizabeth?”

“Good idea. Is cereal OK, Amy?”

Does Alice really need help making cereal?

Elizabeth felt her face flame. Slob was the very worst name she had ever called anybody.

That’s the worst thing she’s ever called anyone and she feels bad about it? Ugh, such a goody-two-shoes.

The Cover: Lila and Amy have weird faces. Actually, Amy looks like Diana Scarwid, who you may remember as Isabel from Lost, the mom from Wonderfalls, Mother Superior from Pushing Daisies…or really any of the other ten million things she’s been in.




  • Kerri September 24, 2014 at 11:26 am

    This cover has always annoyed me! You nailed it.


  • Kylie90210 October 14, 2014 at 8:14 pm

    I thought I read this one but it doesn’t sound familiar!


  • Jill December 12, 2014 at 2:13 pm

    I love that you are doing the twins books. I never read all of them.


  • Whallie January 22, 2015 at 1:17 pm

    What’s with Jessica’s teeth? They look so spaced with a huge overbite, I thought these girls are supposed to be perfect.


  • KannaChan July 24, 2015 at 7:56 pm

    I’ve never really thought Lila was very pretty on the Sweet Valley twins covers. She didn’t really get pretty until high school. She looks too plain on the Twins covers to be pretty enough to be a Unicorn. Sandra Ferris was prettier on her cover. I think Lila only became a Unicorn because she’s rich and Janet’s cousin. Speaking of which, is Janet EVER mentioned in SVH? Or the Unicorns? I wonder what happened to Mandy Miller?


    Shannon Reply:

    Nope, as far as I can remember none of them are ever mentioned in SVH.


  • Steffy October 6, 2015 at 6:29 pm

    Oh I so much agree, the cover is weird plus:
    Isn´t Amy´s hair supposed to be a little more “reddish”? and here she looks slim …check SVT 4

    Lila needs eyelashes on every single cover! she looks sooooo pretty on the cover of SVT “Lila´s secret Valentine”

    The tshirt Amy is wearing actually belongs to Jessica, check SVT 31

    I´m starting to believe that no one owns a cool looking purple tshirt they are all plain and boring


  • Alex Kennedy July 12, 2016 at 6:52 am

    This is one of the oddest SV cover. SVH # 19 is probably the most stunning one of Lila Fowler. Amy’s face looks funny in this one. I wonder if she saved that cast as a reminder of her brief moment in the spotlight.


  • Post a comment

    Threaded commenting powered by interconnect/it code.