Sweet Valley High #139: Elizabeth is Mine
Read part one of this miniseries here.
The Moral of the Story: If your girlfriend cheats on you and you want to win her back, start making out with another girl.
The Big Deal: Science fair
Synopsis:
After Jessica tells Todd that Liz and Devon are making out on the softball field at school, she puts her hand on his in a suggestive way and offers to fool around with him to get back at Liz. Todd is horrified at the idea. He doesn’t believe his sweet, loyal Liz would ever, ever cheat on him, so he leaves Jessica with the food and races over to the high school to see for himself. When Todd gets to school and sees Liz and Devon together, he decides he will win Liz back. Um, hello? Let the bitch go.
Jessica starts scheming. She figures if she can get Todd to start going out with someone else, Liz will break up with Devon so she can get Todd back, leaving Devon free for Jessica. She decides to get in touch with Courtney Kane and do a little matchmaking.
Since Lila is friends with Courtney, Jessica lets her in on the plan and the three of them get together. Courtney is perfectly willing to be Todd’s rebound chick, so she lets Jessica and Lila give her a makeover so she looks more “soft” and “refined.” More like Liz, in other words, and less skanky. Then they parade her in front of Todd, and he starts to wonder if Jessica is on the right track with this revenge idea. But no, he’d rather cry about Liz and try to win her back by giving her the ring he bought for her. Liz puts it in her jewelry box, and Jessica takes it, figuring it will come in handy.
The next part of Jessica’s plan is to get Devon to notice her again. To that end, she makes sure to bump into him while she’s walking down the hall reading her chemistry book. She tells him she’s having trouble in the subject and he plays right into her hands by offering to help her after school. They meet in the library for about two seconds before Jessica gets pissed because Devon makes some comment about not being surprised she sucks at chemistry. Jessica yells at him and tells him to watch out for Liz because she’s a fickle bitch. Much like destiny.
Later, Jessica makes sure Courtney is waiting for Todd after basketball practice. While they’re talking, Jessica, pretending to be Liz, walks across the parking lot. She turns to Todd, sees him with Courtney, reaches into her pocket and puts on Todd’s ring, and then waves at Todd before turning around. Todd is at first excited that Liz seems interested in him again, but then he gets mad that she didn’t want him back until she saw him with Courtney. This pisses him off more than Liz kissing Devon did. And somehow Jessica knew it would. Todd and Courtney leave to go grab some pizza, and Jessica follows them to Guido’s. She calls Liz and asks her to meet her there, and Liz get to the restaurant just in time to see Todd and Courtney making out. Liz runs out the door in horror, but then she starts thinking about things and decides she’s really happy for Todd and she’s going to do whatever it takes to make sure his new relationship works out. That way she’ll be free to be with Devon without feeling guilty.
Then there’s the whole science fair thing. Devon and Liz are going to enter because they’re lab partners. Jessica wants to enter, and she’s sure that Devon will fall madly in love with her if she wins. Unfortunately, Bruce is her lab partner and the best idea they come up with is a volcano. At the fair, Devon is acting all weird and doesn’t really want to win. He didn’t want to enter in the first place, something about people at his old school only knowing him as a smart guy. Yeah, who wants that? When he finds out that somebody (Jessica) ruined his and Liz’s project, he thinks it’s great. Meanwhile, Todd is walking around with Courtney, totally fed up with her snobbishness, and Jessica and Bruce’s volcano blows up.
The next morning, Jessica mentions something to Liz about the ring Todd gave her. Liz decides to give it back to him so he can give it to Courtney. How very noble of her. Liz calls Todd and then goes off to meet him at the Dairi Burger. They get to talking about the ring, and Todd says he saw her wearing it that one day after school. Liz says she never wore it and doesn’t know what he’s talking about. They realize Jessica’s been messing with them both this whole time. As they talk about how much they still care about each other, they hold hands.
Of course, that’s when Jessica comes in with Courtney and Devon. Devon and Todd start yelling and threatening each other in their cool-guy way, and then out of nowhere, Todd gets down on one knee and asks Liz to marry him. I wish I was kidding. Liz is horrified. So is Devon. He grabs Todd and the two of them start going at it. A couple of football players come break up the fight. Liz goes home and locks herself in her room, disgusted with everyone.
Quotes:
Elizabeth would never do this to me, he reassured himself. She would never cheat on me.
What in your experience together would lead you to this line of thinking?
She couldn’t help thinking that Todd never wanted to watch the same movies as she did anymore. They used to watch old classics together all the time. But now he seemed to prefer action movies or psychological thrillers.
Liz, Todd is a dude. You can’t expect him to just watch Casablanca over and over again for the rest of his life.
“How about if we paint it purple?” Jessica suggested. “We could even add tiny yellow flowers or moons.”
Bruce shook his head. “Jessica, volcanoes are brown. And they don’t have little moons on them.”
“Brown?” Jessica asked in alarm. “You want to paint it brown?”
Jessica, seriously, are you still twelve years old?
The Cover: Does the Dairi Burger have a pool table? Nobody has ever mentioned that before. And who the hell are these people? Neither one of these guys look like the Devon from the previous covers.
Tags: Elizabeth: Cheats on Boyfriend, Jessica: Betrayal, Jessica: Manipulation, Liz-Todd Breakup, Liz-Todd Jealousy, Twin Fight, Twin Switch






December 22nd, 2009 at 1:52 pm
I guess they got lazy and decided to just have the twins who played Jess and Liz on the TV show model for the god-awful covers…Cynthia and Brittney Daniel.
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 22nd, 2009 at 2:37 pm
I guess they thought it was easier to take pictures than to draw stuff. I seriously hate these covers.
[Reply]
December 22nd, 2009 at 1:55 pm
Too bad Carl the Orderly couldn’t have broken out of jail and been all “She’s my girl!” and chloroform everyone …
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 22nd, 2009 at 2:35 pm
That would have been amazing. Poor Carl, he just wanted to love her.
[Reply]
December 22nd, 2009 at 3:07 pm
Of *course* Jessica wants to fool around with her sister’s boyfriend… again. And Liz gets *another* marriage proposal? At least this time it comes from a guy who’s known her a long time, which makes it slightly more plausible. (Or does it? He doesn’t actually seem to know her well.) Elizabeth should lock herself in her room permanently, so she doesn’t drive anymore men mad with desire.
I love your snark on those quotes.
Jessica’s contribution to the science fair is so middle-school basic, (and cliched/obvious) it’s no wonder she regresses to 12 years old…I guess. She’s beyond immature. Jess is starting to seem a little… touched in the head, what with her volcano-colour-ignorance, and total lack of morals/conscience/understanding that it’s not okay to scheme and mess with other people’s lives like a psycho puppet-master.
In fact all these characters seem crazy, in one way or another. Todd’s delusion that Liz is a perfect angel, and that getting married would somehow magically solve their problems. (Why can’t he realize it’s his love of action movies that’s driving them apart?!) Liz taking no responsibility for anything, just running away and playing the victim/prize to be won. Devon aggressively pursuing a girl he barely knows, throwing punches and insults all over the place, and acting arrogant, entitled and scarily-persistent… (hey maybe that makes him perfect for Jessica! I’m rooting for those two crazy kids. She should kidnap him and feed him frozen pancakes.)
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 22nd, 2009 at 3:30 pm
I completely agree that pretty much everyone in Sweet Valley has a touch of the crazies. From the lackadaisical parenting to the inappropriateness of school faculty (yes, you, Mr. Collins) to the boys who fall all over themselves to get a second glance from one twin or another. What the hell is wrong with everyone?
And for real, Jessica will forever be twelve years old. A purple volcano with little moons all over it? Blargh.
[Reply]
December 22nd, 2009 at 9:44 pm
A purple volcano with little moons? Oh my God.
I don’t know who’s more pathetic Todd for proposing after Liz cheated on him for the 200th time or Courtney wanting to be rebound girl after how long?
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 23rd, 2009 at 8:53 am
I know, it’s totally sad that Courtney is all, “Hell yeah! I’ll be his rebound!” Like she’s just been sitting around all this time pining after Todd of all people.
[Reply]
megan s. Reply:
December 28th, 2009 at 6:42 pm
what books do Courtney first appear in?
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 28th, 2009 at 9:34 pm
Courtney first appears in Brokenhearted. She goes to Lovett Academy, where Todd went when he first moved back to Sweet Valley.
[Reply]
megan s. Reply:
December 29th, 2009 at 6:52 pm
thanks!
[Reply]
December 22nd, 2009 at 10:31 pm
I seriously love the cover. It’s a Toddpunch in action. Devon’s on the right, Todd’s on the left, for those of you playing at home. And Lila’s there too! Go Lila!
Also, so much awesome Bruce Patman action, so little time. The fact that they’re even making a volcano for a science fair proves that they’re definitely twelve years old.
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 23rd, 2009 at 8:55 am
LOL @ Toddpunch. It is nice to finally see one happen on a cover.
[Reply]
December 22nd, 2009 at 10:35 pm
Also, I forgot to mention how much I love Todd’s apparent psychotic breakdown in these books. He very literally got batshit insane, and a part of me really digs it. I guess ’cause he’s always so punchy and driving-cars-off-a-pier-y.
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 27th, 2009 at 1:21 am
He really does ruin far too many cars, doesn’t he?
[Reply]
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:38 am
Jessica is such a bitch.
And Todd proposed right there in the Dairi Burger?! Oh my god that is too fantastic for words.
” Elizabeth would never do this to me, he reassured himself. She would never cheat on me.
What in your experience together would lead you to this line of thinking?”
Hahahahahahahaha!
[Reply]
Shannon Reply:
December 23rd, 2009 at 8:56 am
Really, what is he thinking? Lorelai’s right, he’s completely lost his mind in these books.
[Reply]
May 6th, 2010 at 9:24 am
It’s just mindboggling. Why would Todd fight for a girl who cheated on him, and why would Devon fight for a girl who is willing to cheat on her boyfriend?
And Jess scheming with Courtney Kane? Didn’t Courtney nearly kill Liz a few dozen books ago? Guess we know how much Liz’s life is worth to Jessica.
[Reply]
August 10th, 2011 at 9:06 pm
“Brown?” Jessica asked in alarm. “You want to paint it brown?”
Didn’t have the brown bedroom? She painted it herself! Oi vey
[Reply]